Oilers win a thriller: Grades for both teams, what to watch in Game 2

Before we go any further, maybe it's fair to establish some ground rules for how to assess this Stanley Cup Final.

Specifically, unless the Edmonton Oilers or Florida Panthers gain a large enough lead to put the game out of reach, the outcome could be decided in the final 10 minutes of regulation or whenever the game-winning goal in overtime (or even double overtime) is scored.

OK. Now that we're on the same page, here's a look at how the Oilers took Game 1 with a 4-3 overtime win Wednesday -- and what it means for both teams going into Friday's Game 2.

Edmonton Oilers Grade: B

Winning the third period in the manner in which the Oilers did was crucial. Not only because it led to overtime, but because it was arguably their most consistent frame in Game 1.

They had the shots in the first period but still trailed. They struggled to gain possession and generate shots in the second, which played a role in why they were down by a goal. Getting a goal from Mattias Ekholm early in the third gave the Oilers their 20th different scorer this postseason. They also outshot the Panthers 14-2, while having a 58.3% shot share, providing them with a sense of control they had been lacking to start.

Although they began overtime on the defensive, their constant ability to apply pressure for the final 15 minutes paid off with Leon Draisaitl scoring the game winner off the power play with 1:06 remaining.

Florida Panthers Grade: B-

They survived the Kasperi Kapanen mini breakaway. They survived the point-blank chance from Trent Frederic at the faceoff circle. They survived when the Oilers had a 5-on-5 sequence they treated like a power play. They survived the Evan Bouchard scoring chance in which he slipped behind the defense for another point-blank opportunity that Sergei Bobrovsky stopped.

Even Destiny's Child, for those familiar, thought the Panthers survived a bit too much.

In the end, they could not survive the Oilers' late overtime power play, during which Draisaitl scored the goal that put the Panthers away.

Every game comes with an inflection point, especially if a team loses. The Panthers had a few. Will it be the second period, which saw them have a 65.2% shot share while breaking through to launch 17 shots on goal -- only to come away with one goal largely due to Stuart Skinner's solid play in net? Will it be the third period, which saw them get just two shots on goal? Or will it be how they couldn't make the most of their dominant start in overtime?

Arda Öcal's Three Stars of Game 11. Leon Draisaitl C, Oilers

Draisaitl didn't have a single goal in the 2024 Cup Final. On Wednesday, he scored 66 seconds into Game 1, then scored the overtime game winner. A sublime start to this year's championship series. Draisaitl has scored or assisted on five of the Oilers' six OT goals over the past two postseasons.

2. Mattias Ekholm D, Oilers

The veteran defenseman scored his first goal of this postseason in his second game back from injury. He became the 20th Oiler to score in these playoffs, which is tied for the second most in a single postseason in NHL history. (The 1987 Flyers and 2019 Blues each had 21 different goal scorers.)

3. Sam Bennett C, Panthers

Bennett had a two-goal effort in a losing cause. He has 12 goals this postseason, the most in a single playoffs in franchise history. Eleven of those goals have been on the road, which is tied with Mark Scheifele (2018) for most road goals in a single postseason in NHL history.

Players to watch in Game 2Kasperi Kapanen RW, Oilers

Remember: This man was on waivers in November. When the Oilers claimed him, it was viewed as a chance to add depth on the cheap, but it turned into something greater. His game-winning goal in the series-clinching Game 5 overtime victory in the Western Conference finals opened the door for more playing time. He almost did it again in Game 1 in overtime, too, but he did get an assist on the game-winning goal.

He has been part of the solution for how the Oilers would fare without Zach Hyman, who sustained an injury in the Western Conference finals that will keep him out the rest of the postseason. Kapanen did his part with three assists, and his five hits allowed the Oilers to maintain the physical edge they've used as part of their identity to reach a consecutive Cup Final.

Sam Bennett C, Panthers

There are two ways to look at what Bennett did in Game 1. The first is that his two-point effort reinforced what has made him a serious candidate to win the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP. Bennett was a front-runner before the game, with a postseason-high 10 goals. Collecting two more gives him 18 points, which is tied with Oilers center Ryan Nugent-Hopkins for fourth place.

The second is that he's going to get paid this offseason. Earlier Wednesday, the Colorado Avalanche re-signed Brock Nelson to a three-year deal worth $7.5 million annually to avoid potentially losing him in free agency. What Bennett did to help the Panthers reach three consecutive Stanley Cup Finals -- and be in a position to claim at least a second title -- is only going to increase what he could command come July 1.

Big questions for Game 2Did the third period and overtime give the Oilers a defensive road map against the Panthers?

The Oilers' path back to the Stanley Cup Final was based on how their defensive structure made life hellish for the Dallas Stars and Vegas Golden Knights, two teams that were in the top five in goals per game in the regular season -- and struggled in the playoffs.

The Oilers had a few challenges in the first period, with Skinner getting partially shielded on the first two goals before having a breakdown in the second period that left their goalie on an island.

From there, the Oilers gave up a combined eight shots over the final frames, with the largest concentration coming in the first five minutes of overtime.

Of course, the Panthers have found breakthroughs against teams with constricting defensive structures, like the Carolina Hurricanes in the Eastern Conference finals. Are the Panthers about to find another in Game 2? Or could the Oilers be on to something that could see them find even more success within their defensive identity?

What is the major takeaway going forward: Their start or their finish?

Here's where it gets complicated -- and it goes back to the earlier statement about teams having inflection points. In the second period, the Panthers were aggressive in a way that hardly anyone has been against the Oilers. That resulted in five high-danger scoring chances, along with an overall sense of control.

That's what made coming away with just one goal -- especially in a one-goal game -- something that could pose questions about how they make the most of those opportunities going forward.

But at the same time, the notion they were forced to survive in an overtime that saw them split the shot share with the Oilers, have more high-danger scoring chances but fail to provide that consistent threat?

That could give the Panthers even more to think about in the coming days ... or maybe they won't question the process, given that they had won their last 31 playoff games in which they held a second-period lead.